• Search

  • Contact

Cayuga Lake Vacation Rentals and Cottages in the Finger Lakes

From Seneca Falls to Ithaca - there are hundreds of Cayuga Lake vacation rentals to choose from. Whether you are looking for an amazing 6 bedroom Cayuga Lake waterfront home for your family reunion, or a cozy bungalow for a weekend retreat - let the links below help you find the perfect home for your vacation. 



Cayuga Lake Area Vacation Rentals

Finger Lakes Premier Properties

142 Lake Street Penn Yan NY 14527 (877) 594-5953 Visit Website

Finger Lakes Premier Properties has the largest selection of lakefront properties along the shores of six lakes throughout the region. Choose from over 250 homes that vary from cozy and private cottages to luxury homes, complete with all of the amenities on your vacation wish list. Finger Lakes Premier Properties also has a great selection of lakefront homes for sale. Visit our website, or call to speak with a reservation specialist to locate your ideal getaway today!

Fish Tail Cove Lakefront Cottage on Cayuga Lake

4855 Springport Cove Cayuga New York 13034 818-414-5253 Visit Website

A lakeside oasis on the east side of Cayuga Lake, surrounded by trees and a forest behind, Fish Tail Cove Cottage sleeps six people with 2 bedrooms and 1.5 bath, and offers a quiet, private and pleasant atmosphere. The spacious and open living area offers the modern comforts of home, including a country kitchen, full laundry facility, flat screen TV, a DVD player, and wireless internet. Enjoy the front deck overlooking the lake for outdoor dining or the covered porch at the back of the house to watch wildlife that frequent the edge of the woods. The long, nearly level yard leads to a flat concrete patio overlooking the waterfront. The gentle slope down to the water brings you to the 60 foot dock, perfect for fishing, kayaking, or mooring your boat. Located in a protected cove, the fishing is excellent.